Tax Bureau's Job to Make a Reasonable Effort to Identify Owners

In Husak v. Fayette County Tax Claim Bureau, 61 A.3d 302 (Pa Commw.) the trial court was correct in setting aside the tax sale. In this case, the Plaintiffs' property was foreclosed in February 2006; Fannie Mae purchased the property at a sheriff's sale and recorded the sheriff's deed. However, the plaintiffs', while still residing on the property, repurchased it from Fannie Mae. At the time of repurchase, Fannie Mae executed a quitclaim deed. A quit claim deed is when the grantor transfers all of his/her interest to the grantee. Any defects associated with the property, such as taxes, now become the grantee's problem. However, the Plaintiffs' never recorded the deed because the Plaintiffs' counsel wanted a notarized deed. Frannie Mae did not send a notarized deed to the Plaintiffs until March 2011, at which time the deed was promptly recorded. 

During the approximate five years that Fannie Mae neglected to provide the plaintiffs with a notarized deed, the Defendants sent tax notices to Fannie Mae. However, these taxes were not paid for in 2008, 2009, and 2010. All tax notices were sent to Fannie Mae and returned with a receipt from one "J.Pierce." As a result of failing to pay taxes, the Defendant recorded a deed for the subject property to Purchaser in November 2010. The Plaintiffs filed a petition to set aside this tax sale.
The court held that the Defendant's must employ common sense when determining the person's responsible for the taxes. Although the Plaintiffs' didn't technically own the property because a deed wasn't filed, the Defendant is still required to seek out the bona fide owners. Here, the court was not persuaded by the Defendant's argument that the Defendant provided notice. Instead, the court questioned why the Defendant never inquired who "J. Pierce" was and if he even worked for Fannie Mae. A signature on a receipt must belong to someone authorized by owner to accept this certified mail. The Plaintiffs never provided Fannie Mae, such authorization. Further, a red-flag should have been raised when on the Record of Deeds it states Fannie Mae as the owner of the property, yet the property had a tended field of corn and crops. Since the Plaintiffs' openly possessed the property and the Defendants did not conduct their due diligence of identifying the true owner, the tax sale was properly set aside.


Why Clients Want Us

  • Thousands of Clients Helped

    We have helped thousands of clients with both small and big cases since the inception of the firm. Our attorney Matthew Weisberg has had the opportunity to fight for the rights of clients before the Supreme Court.

  • Affordable Pricing

    We are committed to providing transparent flat fees that are affordable. Everyone deserves the ability to fight for their rights without the worry of affordability.

  • Over 20 Years of Experience

    Since 2005 our firm has advocated for the rights of clients in Philadelphia and surrounding cities. In addition, our attorneys have been in the legal field for over 20 years bringing immeasurable knowledge with them to the firm.

  • Free Consultations

    We understand the stressful nature of the situation you can be in. Call us for a free consultation and we will strive for a response within 24 hours.

Start Your Free Consultation Today!

Defending Our Clients

See What Our Clients are Saying
  • “They helped me get my life back. I will always remember how empowered I felt after I testified and when the case was over (in my favor!).”

    - Robin R.
  • “When no one would take my legal malpractice case, they did and won!”

    - Doniell W.
  • “Weisberg Law was the only firm that took an interest in our racial discrimination case against a local school district.”

    - Kerry M.

Contact Us to Start Assisting You

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.